Forums

Delicious Library or Librarian Pro?

MacHeist Forums » The Lounge » Delicious Library or Librarian Pro?
mrkowalski

mrkowalski

Automaton Tech

from Purple Pineapple Province
301 posts

I have been using Delicious Library since I acquired a copy with the original MacHeist.

Recently, I received a copy of Librarian Pro in a bundle offered late last year, but I have not put it to use as yet.

I have really liked using Delicious Library, but wish I could easily add custom categories.  I have large collections of books, CDs, Video Games, and DVDs.  Without a good data base, things have a tendency to wander off, never to be seen again.

What do you use for maintaining your media libraries?

Systems: 17in MacBookPro 2011, 2.2Ghz quad core i7, 8GB DRAM, 750GB HDD Mountain Lion;
PowerMac G5 Dual 2.3Ghz, 7GB Memory, 1.5T HDD, Leopard, 23inch Cinema Dispay

March 10, 2009 6:13 am
mil

mil

Sky Pirate

1,265 posts

Delicious Library 2 offers a lot more than version 1 that came with MH. I just upgraded mine over the weekend for $10 using a coupon found in the deals thread here - some goof up happened in the licensing process (on my side and maybe on their side as well), but the Delicious folks were very responsive to my query and sent me a license for 2.x.

SpiderOak - get an additional 1GB space for free when you sign up from this link. I'm late to the SpiderOak referral party. big_smile

March 10, 2009 6:57 am
Lioness

Lioness

Sky Pirate

from Universe (Sweden)
1,469 posts

I hava used Readerware for cataloging my books, CD's and what I had of movies. But when you mention this, I can't even recall when I last did an entry. Must have been a long time ago. So it's not up to date anywhere near. I tested some other things at a point as I was thinking of switching as there were no compatibility to use the inbuilt webcam in MBP for instance to read of the ISBN numbers for books in Readerware, but then I gave up looking for another software as it didn't feel 100%. So another time when feeling for doing more of that kind of organizing I'll check up again and see how the market looks, who knows Readerware might have been upgraded too. lol

http://homepage.mac.com/lheidner/images/happyblue.png

twitter | website
dropbox referral +250MB | minus invite +1GB

March 10, 2009 7:12 am
zdlo

zdlo

Automaton Tech

from San Francisco
257 posts

Before someone says; "How about Bruji applications; DVDpedia, Bookpedia, CDpedia, Gamepedia?"

I tried Delicious Library 2, Librarian Pro, DVDpedia and KavaMovies, but they all had various issues. While DL2 has the only properly working iSight barcode reader, it can't find international products that well. I didn't like DVDpedia and KavaMovies at all. They are not suitable for handling a library. You can't create additional fields. DVDpedia's search functions are terrible.

I'm between DL2 and Librarian Pro, too. I don't have a license of any of them. I just tried the demos.

Join Dropbox free with this link, and earn 500 MB bonus space to your 2 GB free limit!

March 10, 2009 8:18 am
cypher

cypher

Automaton Tech

from UK
477 posts

I've been using Librarian Pro from the previous bundle and it does what I need, but that’s probably pretty basic.

March 10, 2009 8:19 am
mrkowalski

mrkowalski

Automaton Tech

from Purple Pineapple Province
301 posts

I am unaware of the Readerware application.  I may have to download it and compare it to Delicious Library, which is the only one I have any experience with.  Does it provide a graphical representation, or text-only?

I have always been impressed with the visual aspect of Delicious Library, for viewing my catalog list.  I do not have an iSight camera, so I cannot speak for the use of one for barcode reading, but I tried it with a mini DV cam, and the results were pretty mixed.  I don't even bother with that any more.

As I said previously, the biggest problem I have with Delicious Library is the inability to add in additional data bases.  I would like to be able to inventory more than just Books, CD, DVD, and Games.  It would be nice to be able to have separate databases as well.  I have not tried DL2 yet.

For those who have not seen the visual representation provided by Delicious Library, here is a snapshot of part of my book library in DL:

http://img.skitch.com/20090310-bb3ydgh1c946qf9snd7pgdxapy.jpg

Systems: 17in MacBookPro 2011, 2.2Ghz quad core i7, 8GB DRAM, 750GB HDD Mountain Lion;
PowerMac G5 Dual 2.3Ghz, 7GB Memory, 1.5T HDD, Leopard, 23inch Cinema Dispay

March 10, 2009 2:20 pm
daimhin

daimhin

Gearhead

from Gainesville, FL
63 posts

I have used DL for awhile now and love the way it works.  Plus being able to export my library to a website has come in handy to make sure I don't duplicate any purchases.

Green Team Member

March 10, 2009 2:23 pm
toddo

toddo

Automaton Tech

from Southern California
481 posts

I like Delicious Library and with the coupon floating around it is well worth the $20 pricetag. $40 was too much for me to justify before personally but having used the program a bit, it really is one of the simplest ways to catalogue all the stuff you own!

Macheist team: Green Monkeys

March 10, 2009 2:38 pm
macdude56

macdude56

Automaton Tech

from teh Internets
366 posts

I have a copy of Delicious Library 2 and I love it. Sure, both connect to the internet to get information and both can export to an iPod, but I would still use Delicious Library. What I don't like about Librarian Pro is that you can't scan barcodes without a real barcode reader, Delicious Library had that feature whenever it was still in beta.
Delicious Library FTW!!! tongue

I agree: childhood should be a time of innocence, and Bambi's mother shouldn't die, and lap dances should be complementary after the fifth cocktail, but that's not the world we live in
-Charlie Harper

March 10, 2009 2:44 pm
TweakSF

TweakSF

Automaton Tech

from San Francisco, CA
189 posts

I also started with DL from  an earlier MacHeist and have recently upgraded to DL2. DL2 is much easier to work with and the extra categories make life simple by keeping tract of non media related items like Gadgets.

Twitter
Music
 Proud Member of the BLUE Team™

March 10, 2009 2:44 pm
mrkowalski

mrkowalski

Automaton Tech

from Purple Pineapple Province
301 posts

This is really helpful.  I acquired Librarian Pro from a bundle last year, and did nothing more than fire it up and register it.  It sounds like I need to try out DL2 before I waste any time on LP.

Systems: 17in MacBookPro 2011, 2.2Ghz quad core i7, 8GB DRAM, 750GB HDD Mountain Lion;
PowerMac G5 Dual 2.3Ghz, 7GB Memory, 1.5T HDD, Leopard, 23inch Cinema Dispay

March 10, 2009 3:35 pm
atticusrex

atticusrex

Sky Pirate

from dfw
1,025 posts

I've been using DL since it came out.  I've also upgraded.  It is pretty.  The only two real changes now that I wish they allow? 

1. You can publish to the web, but it's not searchable at all, which would help when I'm out book shopping.
2. Upload to eBay or at least port to iSale.

They also have wonderful Tech support and seem to be pretty decent folk to work with.

Been Drinking the Mac KoolAid since 1984
See You in the Land Of The Useless
Neon Charity Films

March 10, 2009 3:47 pm
hoyaman

hoyaman

Big Game Hunter

from Houston, TX
939 posts

I'm one for Librarian Pro.. in it you can store all your media - not just books, but also software licenses, video games, CDs, DVDs, and anything else for which you care to create a category.

Koingo just recently pushed out an update that allow directly exporting a Librarian Pro database to Data Guardian - if you're into that sort of thing.  You can also place the library file anywhere, and access from any machine - Mac or Windows.

And there's always the export to text option.... and import from DL option, if iSight scanning's the thing for you, but you'd like a greater variety of things inventoried.  LP certainly isn't as delicious as DL.

http://www.koingosw.com/products/librarianpro.php

I should add in the disclaimer that I purchased the Koingo utility bundle some time ago (through MacZot, no less), and have lifetime licenses for all of Koingo products.  Never an upgrade fee, ever.

Mozy - backup to the cloud, restore when your computer bites the dust.
BBCODE snippets for TYPINATOR!
DROPBOX: GET 250MB extra FREE!

March 10, 2009 5:07 pm
MrsBatch

MrsBatch

Automaton Tech

from Virginia - USA
407 posts

I have been searching for a way to track my DVDs and was considering setting up my own library using Bento. However, I like the way Delicious Library reads the barcode and fills in the information for you. Less work! I downloaded a trial copy and have been trying to scan in some DVDs, CDs, etc. (I have an iMac with built-in iSight.) I notice that some barcodes are recognized immediately while some it just won't pick up. Also, I notice the DVD jackets tend to pick up a reflection from the screen (glossy screen iMac) which seems to interfere. Some of them I have to hold for a while before they are recognized. Any tips on getting better, more consistent results?

Also, I was trying to find a way in DL to add a custom user-defined field. Is there a way to do this? I see there are a lot of pre-defined fields you can add, but can I add my own?

I like that DL lets me add other items, too. I collect Barbies and need a way to track my ever-growing collection. I was setting up something in Bento, but this makes it easy to get the information in.

ADDITIONAL:
I downloaded DVDpedia (version 4.4.2) to try it out to compare. The same nine movies that DL would not scan, DVDpedia scanned them immediately. There was only one it took a while to recognize. The others I had to barely put them up into the scan area and it recognized them immediately. In the 22 movies I scanned, I was able to do it much faster with DVDpedia. I also see that I can define custom fields. While I like that DL has the options for adding other types of items, I am more impressed with the way DVDpedia was able to quickly scan my movies which is one of the main things I want to do at this time. At $18, I think it's quite good so far.

If you DL users could respond to the questions I raise above, that would be great. I would also like to hear from anyone using DVDpedia what your impressions are.

▛▞▞▟ Proud Member of the BLUE Team™ ▙▚▚▜

March 10, 2009 5:44 pm
majken

majken

Automaton Tech

from Los Angeles
181 posts

Delicious Library has a Publish-to-Web so that you can access your DB from your iPhone.  They have also said that they are working on an iPhone App that will sync your DB.

GO TEAM ORANGE!!!!!

March 10, 2009 7:15 pm
zdlo

zdlo

Automaton Tech

from San Francisco
257 posts

Hey, what about iVideo? It's $10.95 for the next 12 hours.

It seems like a better way to organize all your movies wherever they are. It also has online sync. It can categorize and play your movies. DVDs, CDs, folders, online streaming links... everything!

Join Dropbox free with this link, and earn 500 MB bonus space to your 2 GB free limit!

March 11, 2009 3:39 pm
samanthasquared

samanthasquared

Automaton Tech

from Maryland, USA
237 posts

I have a question about Delicious Library.  I have been trying out the demo, and I am on the fence about buying for two reasons. 
1 - it could be an upcoming loot item.
2 - I can't figure out if you can mark an item as borrowed.

So, is there this capability within DL2, can I somehow....

Oh... nevermind.


So if anyone would like to know, yes, there is the capability.
You have to add friends to the library sidebar and then drag the item icon to the borrower's name.

But... I still think there is the chance that it will show up in loot... maybe?

Should probably get back to work.
Vote for for your favorite WordPress site designs on WP Host... hopefully it's mine.

March 12, 2009 3:24 pm
astudler

astudler

Tinkerer

from Switzerland
42 posts

delicious library rocks! simply to use and nice look and feel!

Open Cloud Computing

March 12, 2009 3:30 pm
zdlo

zdlo

Automaton Tech

from San Francisco
257 posts

samanthasquared wrote:

I have a question about Delicious Library.  I have been trying out the demo, and I am on the fence about buying for two reasons. 
1 - it could be an upcoming loot item.
2 - I can't figure out if you can mark an item as borrowed.

So, is there this capability within DL2, can I somehow....

Oh... nevermind.


So if anyone would like to know, yes, there is the capability.
You have to add friends to the library sidebar and then drag the item icon to the borrower's name.

But... I still think there is the chance that it will show up in loot... maybe?

I'm not buying it for exactly the same reason.

Join Dropbox free with this link, and earn 500 MB bonus space to your 2 GB free limit!

March 12, 2009 3:58 pm
doctor

doctor

Automaton Tech

from Minnesnowta
279 posts

DL was already given in an earlier MH. There is a policy of no repeats so it is very unlikely to happen.

Proud member of Team Green
My DropBox referral

March 12, 2009 4:54 pm
PowerZ

PowerZ

Big Game Hunter

618 posts

Bruji has Pocketpedia for free in the Application Store.  A description can be found here.

Go Orange

Get an extra 250MB for both of us by signing up with my Dropbox referral link!

March 12, 2009 4:57 pm
mil

mil

Sky Pirate

1,265 posts

doctor wrote:

DL was already given in an earlier MH. There is a policy of no repeats so it is very unlikely to happen.

So there's a policy of no repeats for the bundle, but there's nothing to stop it from coming in the Loot (apps have been repeated in the Loot). But this is the useless theoretical argument. Practically, I believe DL 2 will not come anywhere in MH3.

SpiderOak - get an additional 1GB space for free when you sign up from this link. I'm late to the SpiderOak referral party. big_smile

March 12, 2009 5:05 pm
CBeloch

CBeloch

Tinkerer

from Gronau, NRW, Germany
47 posts

I have Delicious Library 2 and i really like it!
nice design, adding Stuff via iSight... just great

Orange? Orange! ORANGE!!!! ,|..|

March 12, 2009 5:10 pm
vortigern

vortigern

Automaton Tech

from Cymru
289 posts

I've own both DL2 and LP, as is obvious from here they both have their pros and cons. For me DL2 was a little limiting but the barcode scanning is great. LP has no barcode scanning (I'm not buying a special scanner) but more options. In the end I've decided to use Bento!

I have started with my "real world stuff" like cameras and climbing gear and stuff and it is going well. I am hoping, but not looked into it yet, to export my DL2 stuff into Bento. That would give me the best of both, using DL2 to capture media stuff and Bento to store everything.

Of course Bento is certainly not without it's faults. I like many other were pretty annoyed by the lack of upgrade price from 1 to 2. So I am still on Bento 1 and will maybe look at Bento 3.

In fact I may end up using either of the other two again, I seem to decide to record all this stuff every year, make a start, never finish. Then decide to do it a different way the following year!

'sdim ots!

March 12, 2009 5:11 pm
jernor

jernor

Gearhead

from Alexandria, VA
68 posts

doctor wrote:

DL was already given in an earlier MH. There is a policy of no repeats so it is very unlikely to happen.

DEVONthink was part of the first bundle. 1password & Cha-Ching were rewards for completing heist 2 from MH1 and they were part of MH2's bundle.

So, I would really like to get DL2, but I'll wait till I see this years bundle (which I'm sure I'll buy.)

“Broken gets fixed. Shoddy lasts forever.”
"I thought what I'd do was, I'd pretend I was one of those deaf-mutes"
Team Orange: Our heroes bleed red, white & orange!

March 12, 2009 5:22 pm
samanthasquared

samanthasquared

Automaton Tech

from Maryland, USA
237 posts

I'll update and say I decided to purchase it with the code I found through another thread:

desertdemocrat wrote:

fr0stbyt wrote:

Delicious Library 50% off!

Download the app and install it.  Launch and go to Delicious Licensor.  Choose Buy New License, upgrade... you are not upgrading, you are buying a new license with a code...

choose I have: Apple Users Group Special Offer code
Enter code: DMS-SO-AUG-PSMUG

Then buy your license for $20 instead of $40.

I bought it, so I can attest to the fact it's a real offer. Check it out if you don't find someone to trade you for the app

I was leery of that offer expiring and then not having it as loot so I figured at worst I would end up with a second license that I could give as a gift to my boyfriend. Or sell it here if anyone will want a second one, I suppose.
I also felt like a lot of people around have been talking about it, so if that many people want the app, they company has little need to put it through for publicity.


So now I have been poking around and one of the big requests has been an iPhone app, so if any one is interested here is where they are in that process:

http://getsatisfaction.com/deliciousmon … e_app_when

Should probably get back to work.
Vote for for your favorite WordPress site designs on WP Host... hopefully it's mine.

March 12, 2009 6:12 pm
spencersage

spencersage

Automaton Tech

from Fort Worth, TX
223 posts

I've been using Delicious Library 2 for quite some time now, and I love it.  The barcode scanning is fantastically responsive, and the database searches can turn up results for almost anything you put into it.  In addition, on the rare occasion that I discover a bug, bug reporting is simple, and the dev team always responds promptly with an update.  I LOVE this program, and I really don't think it could be improved upon too much.

March 12, 2009 6:32 pm

Howard Brazee

Urchin

4 posts

I use Librarian Pro.   When I searched to buy my product it had one big problem - now it has a bigger one.

The problem which I decided to live with is I had to add all short stories in the summary field.

The bigger problem is that the database engine it uses is quite inadequate for the size of my library.   Buying extra RAM didn't help.

I'm searching for something that would allow me to convert my library to some other product and have it be able to run on my Mac without the extremely poor performance.

October 29, 2011 1:41 pm
blue_fireball_eater

blue_fireball_eater

Moderator

from Nashville
2,623 posts

Papers, perhaps?

avatar is from Penfield & Jasper, 1954

October 29, 2011 2:05 pm

Howard Brazee

Urchin

4 posts

Some automated function.   I'm retired - if my genes are true (and my heart attack indicated they might be), I might not live long enough to convert my library catalog to paper.

October 29, 2011 4:42 pm
blue_fireball_eater

blue_fireball_eater

Moderator

from Nashville
2,623 posts

I meant Papers app. I use it for research papers, but you can use it for other things if you prefer.
LINK

avatar is from Penfield & Jasper, 1954

October 31, 2011 5:27 am

Howard Brazee

Urchin

4 posts

My biggest issue with Librarian Pro is that it apparently is based upon Microsoft's engine which can't handle my personal library without being extremely slow. 

My second biggest issue is that the only way I can have a book or magazine listing stories is to have stories in the comments.

Trouble is, I don't see that Delicious Library fixes these problems.

December 10, 2011 1:49 pm

Howard Brazee

Urchin

4 posts

I just want any program that can convert my Librarian Pro library - but not be slow, slow slow with my library.   It's not *that* big, with fewer than 6000 books.

June 30, 2012 8:50 pm
MacHeist Forums » The Lounge » Delicious Library or Librarian Pro?

Become an agent



Keep me posted on more free offers and deals on great Mac software (We'll never sell your email, spam is evil)


As a MacHeist agent you'll be privy to special missions like these, tons of awesome free software, and the best software deals around. What do you want to hear about?

 

Login to MacHeist



As a MacHeist agent you'll be privy to special missions like these, tons of awesome free software, and the best software deals around. What do you want to hear about?